Work
Conversations with my Mother
Maker Janet Cardiff · Work date 2023 · Medium in person · Role control
Description
“On a recreated old workbench with 3 shelves sit 9 vintage telephones, their receivers laying open on the work table surface. The viewer/listener may pick up any of these receivers and listen into conversations that the artist, Janet, had with her 92 year old mother, who lives in Ontario, over the last several years.” The artists’ statement: the work “makes apparent how important telephones have been in connecting families over the past century.” Shown at Fraenkel Gallery, San Francisco. Wooden shelf, telephones, electronics, audio; about 81.5 by 39 by 21.5 inches.
Source. https://cardiffmiller.com/installations/conversations-with-my-mother/
A CONTROL, NOT A WORK. Nine receivers already off their cradles, and the visitor chooses which conversation to listen in on. No call is placed; the calls were placed years ago, between two people, and what is in the gallery is the recording of them.
Which is the thing this piece has in common with the only other entry in the census that works this way. 1-350-FEE-LING lets a caller in 2026 dial a number and hear Joybubbles’ Zzzzyzzerrific Funline, which stopped in the 1990s. Both are playback devices for a conversation that is over. The difference is the one this census is built on: that one you reach by telephone from wherever you are, and this one you reach by going to San Francisco and standing at a workbench. Same content, same intimacy, different delivery — and the delivery is the whole distinction.
Anatomy
Thirteen criteria after Lauren R. Beck. Each carries a source grade: M maker-confirmed, P published, F first-hand, I inferred by the compiler, ? not yet established. Definitions are on the anatomy page.
- Participants listen through headphonesnoP
No headphones. The visitor holds a telephone receiver to the ear, which is the single fact that makes this work worth cataloging and the single fact that keeps it out of the census proper.
- Participants move through space as part of the worksometimesI
Nine instruments along a workbench. The visitor moves between them to choose a conversation, which is closer to browsing than to a route.
- Audio technology is necessaryyesP
Wooden shelf, telephones, electronics, audio. The recordings are the work.
- Site-, situation- or language-specificnoI
A workbench and nine telephones, shown in a commercial gallery and movable.
- Engages with the history of a sitenoI
No documented past of the room it stands in. The history it carries is the telephone’s, not the gallery’s.
- Created for an urban environmentnoI
A portable object. Nothing in it depends on a city.
- Created as an artwork other than theateryesP
A gallery artwork by visual artists, listed in the artists’ own catalog and shown in museums and commercial galleries.
- Intended to be understood as theaternoI
No theatrical vocabulary anywhere in the artists’ description. It is presented as an installation.
- Accidental real-world sights and sounds are importantnoI
A fixed object in a gallery. Nothing accidental is load-bearing.
- Spectator must participateyesP
The receivers lie open and the visitor picks one up. Nothing plays unprompted.
- Has live performers other than the participantsnoP
Recorded. Nobody is on the other end of the handset, which is the whole reason this is a control and not a work.
- Involves game playnoI
No rules, objective or resolution state.
- Uses props other than the listening deviceyesP
The recreated three-shelf workbench the telephones sit on.